Difference between #7 and #8 of Secure password hash storage and a Yii helper extension

Secure password hash storage and a Yii helper extension
security, password, hash, encrypt, random
# Obsolete##NOTE
This article was rewritten as the README of the [Randomness GitHub
repo](https://github.com/tom--/Randomness "Github Repo")


The static class Randomness is a collection of helper methods for web apps that
need random data for security purposes.

Cryptographically-secure random data

Applications may require Cryptographically Secure (CS) random data
to be used in forming, for example, encryption keys, random passwords, session
stream initialization vectors, nonces, secure unique IDs, and some kinds of

PHP's `mt_rand()` is a simple pseudo-random number gnerator designed
for use in Monte Carlo simulations, not in security systems. It is not
cryptographically secure. You can determine the next random
number from previous ones or from knowing the internal state of the generator.

Most operating systems on which PHP typically runs provide a CSPRNG as a service
applications. On Windows it is called
On Linux, OS X, FreeBSD etc.
applications may read the /dev/random pseudo-device. Each of these OSs also
offers a
way for the user to query the status of the CSPRNG. But in PHP, accessing the
can be problematic.

`Randomness::randomBytes` uses several different approaces to read from
the operating system's CSPRNG. It is possible that all of them may fail. In this
case it has an option to get data from the http://www.random.org service and
option to fall back on its own non-crypto-secure generator.

Storing passwords in web apps

There are many tutorials and examples that show storage of passwords in a table.
Often the methods used are substandard and very easy to crack. For example, the
["Agile Web Application Development with Yii1.1 and
PHP5"](http://www.yiiframework.com/doc/) book's example stores
`md5($password)` in the DB and calls it
"encryption". It is not.[ "The Yii Blog
Tutorial"](http://www.yiiframework.com/doc/blog/1.1/en/prototype.auth) is a
little better in
that it uses a salt but it still uses md5 and is easy to crack. Examples of the
same errors abound. The
[yii-user](http://www.yiiframework.com/extension/yii-user) and
are similarly insecure.

You cannot rely on a user to use a (practically) unguessable password or to not
use that password in systems other than yours. And you should not assume that
your server is so secure that an attacker cannot get hold of the password file
or a backup of it.

A very common error I see in what I read and other people's code is fast hashes.
MD5, for example, is very fast. As of Nov
2011 you can check 350 million keys per second on a commodity nVidia processor.
So no matter what you do with salts, the combination of short passwords and fast
brute force checking means your system is open to intruders if you rely on a
non-iterated message digest such as MD5, any of the SHA algos and most of the

The Blowfish hash function is currently considered pretty good. It is designed
to be slow. The
implementation in PHP's `crypt()` is easy to use. Set a cost parameter high
to make a brute force attack really slow. I set it so that it takes about 250 ms
on the production server (a completely arbitrary choice:-).

Each password should have its own random salt. The salt's purpose is to make the
dictionary size in a [rainbow table](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rainbow_table)
or [dictionary attack](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dictionary_attack) so large
that the attack is not
feasible. Salts used with the Blowfish hash do not need to be
cryptographically secure random strings so Randomness's salt generator by
uses the cass's own pseudo-random generator.

Some people advocate resalting every time a user logs in. I think this is only
useful if you also limit the time interval between user logins, e.g. block an
account if the user hasn't logged in in more than *N* weeks.

Using PHP's crypt() to store passwords

People often get confused about how to use implement a password store using
It is actually very simple but it helps to know that:

* It is safe to store the salt together with the password hash. An attacker
cannot use
it to make a dictionary attack easier.

* The string `crypt()` returns is the concatenation of the salt you give it and
hash value.

* `crypt()` ignores excess characters in the input salt string.

`crypt()` has function signature `string crypt (string $str, string $salt)` and
salt string format determines the hash method. For Blowfish hashing, the format
`"$2a$"`, a two digit cost parameter, `"$"`, and 22 digits
from the alphabet
`"./0-9A-Za-z"`. The cost must be between `04` and `31`.

	crypt('EgzamplPassword', '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5t')
		>> '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5e4jVuld5/KF2Kpy.B8D2XoC031sReFGi'

The first 29 characters are the same as the salt string. Anthing appended to the
string argument has no effect on the result:

	crypt('EgzamplPassword', '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5t12345678901234567890')
		>> '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5e4jVuld5/KF2Kpy.B8D2XoC031sReFGi'

		>> '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5e4jVuld5/KF2Kpy.B8D2XoC031sReFGi'

And in particular, pass the value returned from `crypt()` back in as the salt

		>> '$2a$10$1qAz2wSx3eDc4rFv5tGb5e4jVuld5/KF2Kpy.B8D2XoC031sReFGi'

So we can use `crypt()` to authenticate a user by passing the hash value it
gave us previously back in as a salt when checking a password input.


Say we have a `user` table like this

	create table user (
  		id int not null auto_increment primary key,
  		email varchar(255) not null,
  		password_hash char(64) not null,
  		unique key (email)

From a user account generation form assume that we have (already sanitized) user
input in
`$form->email` and `$form->password`. We generate the hash:

	$password_hash = crypt($form->password, Randomness::blowfishSalt());

And insert a row into `user` containing `$form->email` and `$password_hash`.

At user logon assume we again have sanitized user input in `$form->email` and
To authenticate these against the accounts in `user` we select the
`password_hash` field from table `user` where `email` = `$form->email` and,
with that value in `$password_hash`

	if ($password_hash === crypt($form->password, $password_hash))
		// password is correct
		// password is wrong

So there is no need to store the salt in a separate column from the hash value
`crypt()` conveniently keeps it in the same string as the hash.

In Yii

`Randomness::blowfishSalt()` generates a salt to use with `crypt()`, for example
somewhere in the controller action where you register new users:

    $user = new User;
    $user->email = $form->email;
    $user->bf_hash = crypt($form->password, Randomness::blowfishSalt());
    if ($user->save())

To authenticate (refer to the authenticate method in
protected/components/UserIdentity.php of a fresh yiic webapp):

    public function authenticate() {
        $user = User::model()->findByAttributes(array(
            'email' => $this->username,
        if ($user === null
            || crypt($this->password, $user->bf_hash) !==
        ) {
            $this->errorCode = self::ERROR_UNKNOWN_IDENTITY;

This wiki has been replaced by [Use crypt() for password