Difference between #2 and #1 of ACL and RBAC

ACL, rbac, Tree structure, authorization, security, scalability

This HowTo assumes that you have a smattering of ACL in general and of how [the
acl-extension](http://www.yiiframework.com/extension/acl/ "the
ACL-Extension") works basically. It will introduce you into the abstract
and give you a hint on how to use Business-Rules. If you have in-depth
questions, please refer to the extension documentation. 
Using ACL in an RBAC-manner cannot and should never obscure the fact that the
underlying system is still ACL-based. In fact, the Business-Rules are just
another layer in the permission-check plan.
Layers in ACL (at full extend):  
1. General Permission Lookup
2. Regular ACL-Permission lookup  
3. Business-Rules lookup

Please note that Business-rules are indeed independent of the first layer,
although it may be more convenient to combine them. 

Object Representation in a Nutshell 

Each object of the reality has its own representation in ACL. The corresponding
ACL-object is automagically bound to your object and behaves correctly without
requiring any further attention. 
However, you need to interact with those objects in order to configure the
system. As the objects are mapped to ACL-objects and vice versa, you can easily
retrieve and/or identify corresponding objects. There are three ways to achieve

1. **Direct Object Usage**
As ACL-Objects are still objects (to be more specific: models) to Yii, you can
handle them just like all the others: you can retrieve them using their unique

2. **Aliasing**
ACL-Objects can have aliases to simplify their identification (and to use
Business-Rules - more on this later on). Aliases can be random strings, however
they must be unique for one type (see Types later on). As it's a regular
property, you can change them and search them just like you'd do on a normal
The representation can be either as an array or simply a string

array('alias' => "IAmAnalias")

As aforementioned it is possible to use random strings as aliases. However, this
is not endorsed as it imposes pointless complexity (see Business-Rules).

3. **Object-Mapping**
This is the way the ACL-Extension maps the objects internally, if you don't hint
at another strategy. Models are usually unique in their unique ID in conjunction
with their Model-ClassName. So, to identify objects uniquely, you could use
something like:
array('model' => 'Post', 'foreign_key' => $myID)

It's not that convenient and you won't use it that often.

One object per purpose
ACL-Objects can be either AccessControlObjects or AccessRequestObjects.
_AccessControlObjects_ (short:Acos) are all objects which you can access
somehow. This can be Images, Posts and so on, everything you can perform actions

_AccessRequestObjects_ (short: Aros) are all objects which want to access Acos,
which want to perform an action on an Aco.

_Action_ is an action to be performed by an Aro on an Aco. Actions have a name
by which they are identified. Shipped actions (which should not be deleted) are
create, read, update, delete and grant (in full extent). However you can add
your own, arbitrary actions (for exceptions see the Business-Rules section).
Actually you don't need to use the Action-model but you can simply add a row to
your actions-table. 
Note that Actions are always performed on objects (Acos) and never stay alone. 

_Permission_ is a link between an Action, and Aro and an Aco. Permissions work
only positively, i.e. you can only explicitely grant permissions and not
exlicitely deny them. 

How the objects fit together
What the ACL-Extension does is basically to put the ACL-Objects (Aros, Aco) in
two tree-hierarchies (in each tree are only objects of one type). 
This implies that ACL-Objects can have parents and chilren, while chilren
inherit the permissions of their parents. 
Note that hierarchies are _explicitly_ supported for both Aros _and_ Acos. Also,
each Aro and Aco can have _multiple_ parents. The depth of the hierarchy is
unlimited, the lookup is non-recursive.   

Permission Lookup Layers

###The standard way to do it
If an Aro attempts to perform a given Action (or a set of Actions) on a given
Aco, the systems checks if the Aro or one of its parents has the right to
perform the given Action on the Aco or one of its parents. 

###How general rules facilitate life
Sometimes, it can be quite cumbersome to assign permissions for all of the
Just in case you're weary with that, you can assign permissions on a general
basis: You can grant a specific action for all Aros to all Acos of type X, for
example "Post". 

$aro->grant('Post', '* - delete');

Astute readers will have noticed that 'Post' is a simply an alias. Thus, the
object itself is a regular Aco-Object and can be used like any other - also in a
tree structure. 

### Lazy, more lazy, Business-Rules
If you're not only weary with assigning Permissions to specific objects or
objects to groups (one of which you must do if you want to grant rights other
than autoPermissions) but you want to skip the assignment of an object to its
group, Business-Rules are with you. 
Business-rules are simple static functions of the Class "Rules" in the
components-foldre of the ACL-Extension. They get the Aro-Object, the Aco-Object
and the Permission to be performed and return true if the the Action should be
Each Group you want assign Business-Rules to must have an alias. This alias
preceded with "is" will be the name of the Business-Rule:
"Visitor" => "isVisitor". The static functon always bears
the name of the rule. 
Now, you can easily perform something like this:
public static function isAuthor($aro, $aco, $action){
        return $aro->id == $aco->author_id;

Note that Business-Rules can be applied to both Aros and Acos. Also note that
Business-rules are **not being considered in find-Queries** (but _all_ others
are). You'll have to check for yourself using a foreach-loop and the may-method
just as you have to using regular RBAC. 

Please keep in mind that Business-rules might decrease the overall performance
of your application. You might want to change the
"enableBusinessRules" to a more specific value (see the docs) if you
don't need the power in its fullest extent. 

Write new article